Sometimes preservation starts with a grand building. Sometimes it starts when neighbors look out their windows and wonder what is about to happen to their street.
Recently, residents of Eden Street in South Buffalo reached out to Preservation Buffalo Niagara after seeing signs that their street
could be headed for paving work. Their concern centered on the two-block stretch between McKinley Parkway and Abbott Road, where the roadway itself is historic: a remarkably intact brick street laid nearly a century ago. In response, PBN prepared and submitted a local landmark application for Eden Street, beginning the process of formally recognizing and protecting this important piece of South Buffalo’s historic landscape.
A Street Worth Preserving
The eastern section of Eden Street was laid out in 1928 as part of a small residential subdivision developed by Christ Forbach, a German-born master builder and contractor who operated his own construction business in Buffalo. By the late 1920s, brick was already beginning to give way to asphalt and concrete as the preferred material for American streets. Eden Street was built near the end of an era when vitrified brick was valued for creating durable, permanent roadways capable of handling urban traffic and Buffalo’s demanding freeze-thaw cycles.
Walk down Eden Street today, and that history is not hidden behind a wall or tucked away in an archive. It is the street itself. The exposed brick, historic alignment of the roadway, sandstone curbing, sidewalks, mature residential streetscape, and surrounding houses collectively tell the story of how this section of South Buffalo developed.
Buffalo once had many more brick-paved streets. As generations of road projects introduced asphalt and concrete, surviving examples became increasingly uncommon. Eden Street is among the surviving Buffalo brick streets documented by Brick Streets of WNY, alongside streets including Eaglewood Avenue, Timon Street, Viola Park, and Ardmore Place. The organization’s website currently documents 64 brick streets in Buffalo.
Preservation is about more than individual buildings. Sidewalks, curbs, parkways, street trees, public spaces, and the materials beneath our feet are all part of the physical landscape that gives a neighborhood its identity.
The Landmark Process Is Underway
PBN became involved after Eden Street residents raised concerns about paving and prepared the local landmark application at no charge to the neighborhood or its residents. 27 neighbors had already signed in support of Eden Street’s landmark designation.
Local landmark designation recognizes that the historic roadway is part of Buffalo’s built heritage and provides an established preservation review process when changes are proposed. Most importantly, this effort started with the people who live there. Eden Street residents saw something meaningful in their neighborhood and spoke up before it could disappear.
Click to access Eden-Street-landmark-narrative.pdf
Call to Action: Help Save Eden Street
Are you an Eden Street resident? We want to hear from you. Email Emily Jarnot at emily@pbnsaves.org with your name, address, whether you support the landmark designation, and any questions or concerns you may have.
Tell Christopher P. Scanlon you support landmarking Eden Street. Eden Street is located within Buffalo’s South District. You can email cscanlon@city-buffalo.com or visit the City of Buffalo’s official South District contact page: Staff Directory • Christopher Scanlon
Learn more about Buffalo’s surviving brick streets. Visit Brick Streets of WNY to explore Eden Street and other surviving historic brick streets throughout Western New York. Buffalo – Brick Streets
Support PBN’s work. Researching and preparing a landmark application takes real staff time, from archival research and writing to photography, community outreach, and meetings at City Hall. PBN undertook this work without charging Eden Street residents. Supporting PBN allows us to keep showing up when a neighborhood raises its hand and says, “This place matters.”

