Landmarking Eden Street – Take Action Now!

Sometimes preservation starts with a grand building. Sometimes it starts when neighbors look out their windows and wonder what is about to happen to their street.

Recently, residents of Eden Street in South Buffalo reached out to Preservation Buffalo Niagara after seeing signs that their street could be headed for paving work. Their concern centered on the two-block stretch between McKinley Parkway and Abbott Road, where the roadway itself is historic: a remarkably intact brick street laid nearly a century ago.

The eastern section of Eden Street was laid out in 1928 as part of a small residential subdivision developed by Christ Forbach, a German-born master builder and contractor who operated his own construction business in Buffalo. By the late 1920s, brick was already beginning to give way to asphalt and concrete as the preferred material for American streets. Eden Street was built near the end of an era when vitrified brick was prized for creating durable, permanent roadways capable of handling urban traffic and punishing freeze-thaw cycles.

Walk down Eden Street today and that history is not hidden behind a wall or tucked away in an archive. It is the street. The texture and color of the exposed brick, the historic alignment of the roadway, sandstone curbing, sidewalks, mature residential streetscape, and surrounding houses collectively tell the story of how this section of South Buffalo developed.

Buffalo once had many more brick-paved streets. As generations of road projects introduced asphalt and concrete, surviving examples became increasingly uncommon. Historic brick remains visible in places including Eaglewood Avenue, Timon Street, Viola Park, Ardmore Place, and Niagara Falls Boulevard. In fact, Buffalo designated the brick-paved section of Niagara Falls Boulevard between Main Street and Kenmore Avenue as a local landmark all the way back in 1987. In 2025, the Hamlin Park Historic District was amended to recognize the significance of its surviving brick streets as well.

Preservation is about more than individual buildings. The places we inherit are also shaped by sidewalks and curbs, parkways and public spaces, street trees and, yes, the materials beneath our tires and feet. They are pieces of the same physical landscape, and together they give a neighborhood its sense of place.

Action Items
Are You a Resident of Eden Street?

We want to hear from you! We have 27 signatures from your neighbors showing support for Eden Street’s landmark designation!

Please email us your name, address, stance, and any questions or concerns you may have.
Send emails to: Emily, emily@pbnsaves.org

Did You Know There is a Website Devoted to WNY’s Brick Streets?

Brick streets are so charming and add great curb appeal to any neighborhood. This website documents the brick streets that remain in WNY and the current condition of them.

www.brickstreets.org

Want to support our ongoing work? Donate here to our Annual Appeal today.
 

Save on Taxes and Invest in Preservation

Would you rather pay more in federal taxes or support a cause you care about?

A new federal tax provision makes charitable giving more beneficial than ever. In previous years, taxpayers generally needed to itemize deductions to receive a federal tax benefit for charitable contributions to organizations like Preservation Buffalo Niagara, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit.

For tax year 2026, taxpayers who take the standard deduction may also claim a deduction for qualifying cash gifts to eligible charities. The deduction is capped at $1,000 for individual filers and $2,000 for married couples filing jointly.

That means your support for Preservation Buffalo Niagara can help protect our region’s historic places while also reducing your taxable income.

Consider making a gift before December 31, 2026, to take advantage of this new tax-saving opportunity and help preserve Western New York’s architectural and cultural heritage.

For more information please call, Patrick McNichol at:
(716) 852-3300, ext 105.

She’s Still Got It! Doors Open at the Eliza Quirk House

WOW, Buffalo! Thank you to everyone who came out to 72 Sycamore for Doors Open! Over 14 tours, more than 200 people walked through the doors of the Eliza Quirk House to see the building and learn about the remarkable woman who built it. The questions were great, the curiosity was contagious, and the love for this little building was everywhere!

Meet Eliza

Eliza Quirk’s life doesn’t fit neatly into any one box. She came to America from Ireland with very little, at a time when women had few paths to independence, and she built a real estate portfolio across Buffalo. Around 1846, she built 72 Sycamore, which operated as a brothel, part of how she became one of the wealthiest women in her neighborhood.

She also wasn’t afraid of the law. One of her fines in the 1850s was $1,000, which would be close to $40,000 today! Eliza paid it and moved on. In her later years, she turned to religion, yet her obituary still summed her up as having lived a “bold bad life.”

Her story is complicated, and that’s exactly why it matters. It reminds us that the people who shaped Buffalo weren’t always the ones in the history books, and their buildings still carry their stories.

What Visitor Saw:

What makes 72 Sycamore so special is how much of it survives. Original doors, trim, layout, and even wallpaper are still here, nearly 180 years later! Walking through it feels like stepping straight into Buffalo’s past.

What’s Next For Her:

The Eliza Quirk House is coming back to life! Water is back on, stabilization is done, permits are approved, $1.8 million in grants is secured, and work has begun. When she’s finished, she’ll be PBN’s first permanent home and the region’s first Preservation Resource Center: a place to learn, gather, and keep Buffalo’s buildings standing for generations.

Help us finish the job!

We have just $300,000 to go, and every gift keeps the crews working. If you came to a tour, or wish you had, please give today and help Eliza prove she’s still got it!

Donate to Save 72 Sycamore

A huge thank you to our volunteers, our tour guides, and every single person who showed up. See you at the grand opening!

With Love,
Bernice and the PBN team

Doors Open Buffalo: Explore the Eliza Quirk House at 72 Sycamore Street

This year, during Doors Open Buffalo, Preservation Buffalo Niagara invites visitors to step inside one of Buffalo’s oldest surviving downtown buildings and discover a remarkable chapter of our city’s past: the Eliza Quirk House at 72 Sycamore Street.

The Eliza Quirk House was constructed around 1848 by entrepreneur Eliza Quirk and remains one of the oldest buildings in downtown Buffalo. Today, it is recognized for its historic significance as both a City of Buffalo Landmark and a property listed on the National Register of Historic Places.

During Doors Open Buffalo, guests will have the opportunity to explore this pre-Civil War building and learn about its ongoing transformation. Preservation Buffalo Niagara is rehabilitating the structure to serve as its permanent headquarters and future Preservation Resource Center, a community-focused hub dedicated to preservation education, technical assistance, workshops, research, and public programming.

Visitors will be able to see firsthand how historic preservation is bringing new life to this important Buffalo landmark. The project will preserve the building’s historic character while creating a vibrant community resource that will serve homeowners, neighborhood organizations, preservation advocates, students, and researchers for generations to come.

In addition to touring the building, Doors Open Buffalo visitors will have the opportunity to meet several organizations that share a commitment to Buffalo’s history, neighborhoods, and community pride. We are excited to welcome the following guest organizations:

Buffalo’s Badass Babes

Celebrating and sharing the stories of the remarkable women who have shaped Buffalo’s history and culture.

Central Terminal Restoration Corporation

Learn about the ongoing restoration and revitalization efforts at the iconic Buffalo Central Terminal, one of the city’s most recognized landmarks.

Buffalo Fire Historical Society

Discover Buffalo’s firefighting heritage through photographs, artifacts, and stories that preserve the legacy of the city’s fire service.

East Side Parkway Coalition

Explore the work being done to celebrate, protect, and reconnect Buffalo’s historic parkway system and strengthen neighborhoods across the East Side.

Whether you’re a lifelong Buffalonian, a history enthusiast, an architecture lover, or simply curious about the future of one of downtown’s oldest buildings, we hope you’ll stop by 72 Sycamore Street during Doors Open Buffalo.

Come experience a rare opportunity to walk through Buffalo’s past while seeing preservation in action and imagining what the future holds for this extraordinary landmark.

Read More about 72 Sycamore here.

We look forward to welcoming you to the future home of Preservation Buffalo Niagara’s Preservation Resource Center at the historic Eliza Quirk House.