Revitalizing New York’s Largest Historic Landmarks: Why the White Elephant Tax Credit Matters

Across New York State, some of our most iconic historic buildings still sit vacant—massive, architecturally significant structures that have shaped the identity of their communities for generations. These “White Elephant Buildings” are too important to lose, yet too large and complex to redevelop without meaningful support. A new piece of legislation, the White Elephant Historic Tax Credit Enhancement Act (S.6021A/A10366), offers a path forward.

For more than fifteen years, the New York State Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credit (NYSHTC) has been one of the state’s most effective revitalization tools. As the fact sheet notes, the program has “leveraged over $17 billion in total project costs from nearly 1,500 projects,” creating thousands of housing units, supporting small businesses, and fueling local economies. These successes demonstrate what’s possible when preservation and smart investment work hand in hand.

But the largest and most challenging buildings—places like the Richardson Olmsted Campus, Central Terminal, AM&A’s, the Hudson River State Hospital, and the Glenwood Power Station—require more. Their rehabilitation costs often exceed $50 million, and many have been vacant for a decade or longer. Without additional incentives, they remain stuck in limbo: too expensive to redevelop, too significant to demolish, and too deteriorated to leave untouched. The proposed legislation directly addresses this gap.

What the White Elephant Enhancement Act Would Do

The bill strengthens the NYSHTC in two key ways:

1. Increases the per‑project cap from $5 million to $15 million
This expanded cap applies specifically to White Elephant Buildings—very large, long‑vacant structures with exceptionally high rehabilitation costs. This change would finally make it feasible for developers, nonprofits, and communities to take on these transformative projects.

2. Extends the entire NYSHTC program from 2030 to 2037
Large‑scale rehabilitations require years of planning, financing, and construction. Extending the program ensures that these projects can be responsibly developed without racing against an expiration date.
Importantly, the fact sheet emphasizes that “no tax credits will be claimed until the projects are completed,” and that the state should expect no fiscal impact in the upcoming year due to the long timelines of these complex rehabilitations.

Why This Matters

Without improved incentives, these monumental buildings continue to generate no tax revenue and often require public dollars simply to stabilize or maintain them. With the right tools, they can become engines of economic development—creating jobs, housing, commercial space, and renewed community pride.
New York has already seen what historic tax credits can accomplish. Strengthening the program for the state’s most challenging buildings is the next logical step.

A Call to Action

The Preservation League of New York State and partners across the state are urging legislators to co‑sponsor the White Elephant Historic Tax Credit Enhancement Act (S.6021A Baskin / A10366 Hunter). Supporting this bill means supporting community revitalization, economic development, and the preservation of irreplaceable historic places.

These buildings have waited long enough. With the right investment, they can once again become anchors of vibrant, thriving communities.

Historic Homeowner Tax Credit Advocacy Alert – From the Preservation League of New York State

 

Historic Homeowner Tax Credit (S4057A Fahy/A5453 Woerner)

As of January 1, 2025, the homeowner portion of the NYS Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credit Program stepped down significantly in value from a maximum of $50,000 per project to $25,000. Additionally, the rebate provision of the credit, which has been so helpful to those homeowners without the state tax liability to accept the full value of the credit and instead receive it as a rebate, has been allowed to expire.

In response, there has been introduced in the NYS Legislature a bill that would restore the Homeowner Credit to its pre-January 1, 2025, value. In the Senate it is bill S4057A sponsored by Senator Patricia Fahy and in the Assembly it is A5453 sponsored by Assemblymember Carrie Woerner (click the links to read the full legislation and see the current list of co-sponsors).

Because tax credits have a fiscal impact on New York State, it is likely that any fix to the tax credit program will have to be a part of the FY27 Budget now being negotiated in Albany. For it to be included, legislators will need to sign on as co-sponsors of the legislation and request that leadership include the bill’s language in the final FY27 Budget.

Please reach out to your legislators now and ask them to co-sponsor S4057A Fahy/A5453 Woerner and tell leadership it is time to restore the Homeowner Tax Credit.

Click here for a fact sheet on the legislation for you to share.

Help us spread the word: You can find all of this information on our website here.

Not sure who your elected representatives are? Click here to find your NYS Senator and here to find your NYS Assemblymember.

For more information or if questions arise, please reach out to League President Jay DiLorenzo via email at jdilorenzo@preservenys.org.

PBN’s Holiday Gift Guide

The holidays are here, and with them comes the familiar question: What do you get for someone who already has everything? As consumerism shifts toward more intentional and meaningful choices, we invite you to give gifts that celebrate heritage, community, and the stories that shape Buffalo and beyond.

This year, Preservation Buffalo Niagara has curated a gift guide that blends history, architecture, and preservation into thoughtful presents that truly keep on giving.

Erie Canal Legacy: Architectural Treasures of the Empire State

Erie Canal Legacy

By Andy Olenick (Photographer) and Richard O. Reisem (Collaborator)

This beautifully photographed volume captures the architectural gems along the Erie Canal, showcasing the enduring legacy of one of New York State’s most transformative projects. It’s more than a book—it’s a journey through time, offering readers a chance to appreciate the structures that tell the story of the Empire State. Perfect for history buffs, architecture enthusiasts, or anyone who loves the canal’s role in shaping our region.

Changing Places: Remaking Institutional Buildings

By Lynda H. Schneekloth, Marcia F. Campagna, and Barbara A. Feuerstein

This insightful collection explores how institutional buildings evolve to meet new needs while honoring their original purpose. With essays and case studies, it’s a thoughtful examination of preservation and adaptation, making it an ideal gift for those interested in the intersection of architecture, community, and change.

Membership with Preservation Buffalo Niagara

PBN Membership, a gift that keeps on giving.

A Membership with Preservation Buffalo Niagara (PBN) is more than just a present—it’s an investment in community, culture, and history.

  • Free tours of select architectural landmarks, including Louis Sullivan’s iconic Guaranty Building
  • Access to preservation tools, such as our vetted contractor list and planning resources
  • Connection to a growing network of people dedicated to protecting Buffalo’s architectural heritage

Every membership supports preservation efforts across Western New York, ensuring our historic neighborhoods and buildings continue to thrive. It’s a gift that strengthens community and celebrates the spirit of Buffalo.

Explore membership tiers and give the gift of preservation today.

All gifts, including the Individual tier membership, can be purchased here:

https://givebutter.com/2025-Holiday-Gift-Guide

 

Niagara Falls Historic Tax Credit & Developers Forum – December 9th at 2:30pm.

The City of Niagara Falls will be hosting a historic tax credit and developer’s forum on Tuesday Dec. 9th at 2:30pm at the Niagara Falls Library, with a focus on the Main Street/Bridge District corridor.

If you are interested in working in Niagara Falls or buying a vacant historic building – this is your chance!

DevelopersForumFlyer