St. Ann’s Church remains one of Buffalo’s most significant and vulnerable historic structures. Unfortunately, recent site observations indicate that conditions at the property are worsening—and at an alarming pace.
Preservation Buffalo Niagara is deeply concerned by the extent of recent material removal and the growing exposure of the building’s structure to the elements.
Importantly, St. Ann’s is a designated City of Buffalo local landmark and has been determined eligible for listing on the National Register of Historic Places—making it a strong candidate for historic tax credits that could support its rehabilitation. Despite these tools and protections, the building continues to deteriorate.
Significant Loss of Roof Protection
On the western side of the building, approximately half of the copper roof over the lower side aisle has been removed. This has left large sections of underlayment exposed, along with multiple visible holes in the roof system.
These openings are not minor. They represent direct pathways for water infiltration, which will accelerate structural deterioration if not addressed immediately.
Removal of Critical Building Components
Additional material loss has been observed across several key areas of the structure, including:
-
Removal of metal lining from the stone gutter systems built into the tops of the walls
-
Missing ridge caps along portions of the roof
-
Extraction of metal from the southwest valley of the crossing, resulting in a large opening at a critical drainage point
These elements are not decorative—they are essential to managing water and protecting the building envelope. Their removal significantly increases the risk of widespread damage.
Exposure of the Tower and Upper Structure
The rear lantern and steeple have also been compromised. Much of the metal cladding has been removed, exposing underlying wood framing and architectural elements, including railings.
In addition, attic windows throughout the structure are now open or missing entirely. These openings appear to have been used to access roof elements, including gutters, snow guards, and lightning protection systems. As a result, the interior is now increasingly exposed to weather and moisture intrusion.
Escalating Risk
There is little visible evidence of stabilization or active stewardship on site. In contrast, the pattern of material removal suggests that stripping activity has intensified over time.
Without immediate intervention, the current conditions will lead to rapid and potentially irreversible damage.
A Call for Action
Preservation Buffalo Niagara is urging the property owner to take immediate steps to secure and stabilize the building.
At a minimum, this includes:
-
Closing and protecting all roof openings
-
Securing exposed structural elements from further weather damage
-
Reestablishing basic building envelope protections
-
An alarm system to be installed
St. Ann’s is not just another vacant structure. It is a defining piece of Buffalo’s architectural and cultural history. The loss of this building would be a significant and avoidable setback for the community—especially when viable rehabilitation tools already exist.
We remain ready to assist in identifying pathways toward stabilization and reuse. However, time is a critical factor, and action must be taken now to prevent further deterioration.
Photographs courtesy of: Adam Hudymiak